QUOTE (teal @ Jan 26 2008, 07:41 PM)

^ well i've never really said korean rock was hard. it's just that when i look for harder sounds it ends up being metal or something. maybe i was looking really deep or something. but yeah, i do agree korean rock is more like what you described, like pop-rockish. and folk style seems pretty popular. i'm not surprised with hiphop being being though , from my pov - seo taiji and kids. lately though, i've been wondering why rock hasn't taken off mainstream. like you wrote could be the talent/effort factor / nature of the korean music industry that isn't that receptive. i could add the mandatory military service. the other thing i'm thinking is the size of the korean music market is. not too big. so where could the money be made. i dunno should rock be more "glamorized" to "encourage" people to get into that style of music? but then i know there are some fans of indie music who don't want that to happen to korean rock.
in anycase, i guess one can't want everything.
I think rock deserves its niche in a close-minded country like Korea. In no other country has rock ever been this degraded in value. '96 to '08, 11 going-on 12 years and not one famous Korean rock band recognized internationally? Let alone 2? There's a part of me that refuses to accept that. It's the mindset of the people. That's a cultural issue.
Then there's the talent issue. Rock is revered worldwide because there really is a lot more talent and effort put into it. Musicians in the rock industry are still learning their trade in their mid-20s, 30s, 40s, etc. It's a combination of skill and talent that a teen-idol-ridden country like Korea cannot easily and readily grasp. They're more into fast fame, and doing easy work like singing and dancing for five minutes with music made for them. That's a work/talent issue.
Finally, regarding fame and fandom, I'll let you in on something. Bands in the west compete for the top or to do something different and get recognized for it. The more recognition, the better, because that's their reward. Why would they be happy staying lowkey and having only 50 people show up to their concert? How are they going to feed themselves? Even in Japan, Jrock became famous for their innovative styles and earnest competition amongst themselves outside of the West. So they earn the respect of the West. They get western fans. And fans should also act wise: every fan who really loves their band wants them to be the best. It's a selfish attitude to keep them to yourselves. You're never going to find success that way. It's contradictory to the efforts of a band.
I'm still sitting here, wondering who I should respect in Krock, let alone find out what Krock really is all about. And you know what I find, NOTHING.